can you buy individual crayola colored pencils

Buy Individual Crayola Colored Pencils: Where to Find and Best Deals

By Mark Taylor
AD

When searching for specific art supplies, the question often arises: can you buy individual crayola colored pencils? While the brand is famous for its boxed sets, the desire to find a single favorite color or replace a broken pencil without opening an entire new set is a common dilemma for artists, students, and parents. The short answer is yes, but the journey to finding them requires understanding the different product lines and where to look, as the standard offerings are not always sold as singular units at a retail store.

Understanding the Crayola Product Ecosystem

Crayola organizes its colored pencils into distinct categories, which dictates their availability. You have the core Classic colored pencils, the smoother layering Colored Pencils XL, the vibrant Premier line, and the sharpened Color Wonder options. The structure of these products differs significantly; Classic boxes contain a specific palette of colors designed to work together, meaning the company’s primary distribution method is the full set. Consequently, you will rarely find a single loose Classic pencil sitting on a store shelf like a loose leaf, as they are packaged to move the entire collection.

Where to Find Individual Units

Although uncommon in traditional brick-and-mortar stores, it is possible to purchase individual pencils or specific color packs. The most reliable avenue is the official Crayola website or major online marketplaces like Amazon. On the Crayola site, you might find "marker & crayon refill packs" or promotional bundles that include a few specific shades. Online retailers, however, often become the solution for replacing a single broken pencil or acquiring a color that is otherwise hard to find in a set. You can usually search for the specific color name, such as "Crayola Peach" or "Crayola Teal," to see if individual listings exist.

AD
100 Colored Pencils with Colors of the World
100 Colored Pencils with Colors of the World
Back to School: Crayola Colored Pencils Featuring Colours of The World, 150 Count
Back to School: Crayola Colored Pencils Featuring Colours of The World, 150 Count
Complete List of Current Crayola Crayon Colors
Complete List of Current Crayola Crayon Colors
Product Line Typical Packaging Individual Availability
Classic Colored Pencils 24, 48, 64 count boxes Rare in stores; possible online
Colored Pencils XL 12, 18, 36 count boxes Rare; check online marketplaces
Crayola Premier Professional grade sets Highly unlikely; sold in collections

Retailer Strategies and Limitations

Major office supply or art stores like Staples, Target, or Michaels often stock only the large pre-packaged boxes. Their inventory systems are optimized for high-volume items, and keeping a wide range of individual colors is not cost-effective for them. If you are looking for just one color, relying on a local store can result in frustration. However, some stores might sell multipacks that include a few specific shades, such as skin tone colors or neon shades, which gives you a smaller, more curated selection than a full box.

Cost Considerations and Alternatives

Buying individual pencils, especially online, can sometimes be more expensive than purchasing a new set. Shipping costs and the per-unit price often make the single pencil option a less economical choice. If you are looking for a specific shade, it is worth comparing the price of buying a whole new set with a color you already have versus buying the one color individually. Alternatively, if the issue is that the pencil is too short to hold comfortably, you might invest in a simple hand-held pencil sharpener or a model that sharpens the sides to extend its life, rather than seeking a replacement.

Crayola Erasable Colored Pencils 12 Ct Pre-sharpened 68-4412
Crayola Erasable Colored Pencils 12 Ct Pre-sharpened 68-4412
Crayola Colored Pencils, 24 Count
Crayola Colored Pencils, 24 Count
Complete List of Current Crayola Colored Pencil Colors
Complete List of Current Crayola Colored Pencil Colors

Custom Solutions for the Artist

For the artist who needs a specific hue that Crayola does not offer in their current lineup, the market provides alternatives. Many art supply brands sell colored pencils in the same hardness scale and are often sold individually in art stores. You can use these to supplement your Crayola collection. Furthermore, if you are attached to the Crayola wax formula but need a color they don’t make, you could purchase a set close to your desired palette and manually sort the pencils, effectively creating your own "individual" purchase based on your specific needs.

24 Crayola Colors of the World Colored Pencils
24 Crayola Colors of the World Colored Pencils
Crayola Color Slicks
Crayola Color Slicks
2025 Crayola Limited Edition Retired Colors; Crayons, Colored Pencils and Markers
2025 Crayola Limited Edition Retired Colors; Crayons, Colored Pencils and Markers
1990 64 Crayola Crayons
1990 64 Crayola Crayons
Every Crayola Crayon Color Ever Made
Every Crayola Crayon Color Ever Made
Sort, Name and Unbox 150 Crayola Colored Pencils featuring Colors of the World
Sort, Name and Unbox 150 Crayola Colored Pencils featuring Colors of the World
State Crayon Collection: What's Inside the Box
State Crayon Collection: What's Inside the Box
six crayola pencils with different colors and designs on them, all in the same package
six crayola pencils with different colors and designs on them, all in the same package
crayons 24 count box of 24 colors
crayons 24 count box of 24 colors
crayola colored pencils are in a yellow box with the words, coloured pencils
crayola colored pencils are in a yellow box with the words, coloured pencils
100 Colored Pencils Color Order! Sort All the 100 Crayola Colored Pencils
100 Colored Pencils Color Order! Sort All the 100 Crayola Colored Pencils
Crayola Colored Pencils, 50ct. | Michaels®
Crayola Colored Pencils, 50ct. | Michaels®
120 Crayola Colored Pencils Color Swatches!
120 Crayola Colored Pencils Color Swatches!
many different colored crayons are lined up together
many different colored crayons are lined up together
2008 Crayola 50th Birthday Crayons
2008 Crayola 50th Birthday Crayons
crayon colored pencils in a yellow box on a white background with the words, colored pencils 24
crayon colored pencils in a yellow box on a white background with the words, colored pencils 24
2025 Crayola Limited Edition Retired Colors; Crayons, Colored Pencils and Markers
2025 Crayola Limited Edition Retired Colors; Crayons, Colored Pencils and Markers
a pile of colored crayons sitting next to each other on a carpeted floor
a pile of colored crayons sitting next to each other on a carpeted floor
2019 NEW Crayola COLORS Review and 24 Crayons
2019 NEW Crayola COLORS Review and 24 Crayons
a bunch of different colored pencils with writing on them
a bunch of different colored pencils with writing on them
AD