The Ultimate Colored Pencils Review: Top Picks for Artists and Students
Choosing the right set of colored pencils can feel overwhelming with the sheer number of options lining the shelves of art stores and the endless listings online. Whether you are a seasoned illustrator or a student just beginning to explore color theory, understanding the nuances between wax, oil, and watercolor pencils is essential for your creative journey. This review breaks down the key characteristics of leading brands and applications to help you make an informed decision without wasting time or money.
Wax-Based Pencils: The Classic Workhorse
Wax-based colored pencils remain the most popular choice for beginners and professionals alike due to their creamy texture and reliable performance. Brands like Prismacolor Premier and Faber-Castell Polychromos dominate this category, offering rich pigmentation and smooth laydown that blends beautifully. The wax binder allows for vibrant color saturation, but it also means the medium can become waxy and shiny if overused, which might affect adhesion on certain papers.
Blending and Layering
One of the significant advantages of wax pencils is their ability to layer colors effectively. You can build depth gradually, creating stunning gradients and realistic textures. However, because the wax resists water, techniques like burnishing—applying heavy pressure to create a polished surface—work best with these pencils. Artists often favor them for portraiture and detailed work where smooth transitions between hues are critical.
Oil-Based Pencils: Precision and Control
For those who prioritize control and accuracy, oil-based pencils provide a distinct alternative. Caran d'Ache Luminance and Tombow MONO are standout examples known for their firm cores and minimal wax bloom. Unlike wax pencils, these do not soften easily with heat, making them ideal for technical drawings and sketches that require sharp, precise lines without the risk of smudging.
Durability and Resistance
The durability of oil-based pencils is another compelling reason for artists to keep them in their toolkit. The cores are less prone to breaking, and the consistent pigment flow ensures that the color remains true across the entire length of use. This reliability is particularly beneficial for professionals working on long projects where consistency is non-negotiable.
Watercolor Pencils: Expanding the Medium
Watercolor pencils, such as those from Derwent and Koh-i-Noor, bridge the gap between dry drawing and wet media. These pencils allow artists to sketch with precision and then activate the pigment with water, creating washes and blends reminiscent of traditional watercolor painting. The versatility makes them a favorite among travelers and mixed-media artists who value portability and flexibility.
Techniques and Applications
Using watercolor pencils effectively requires mastering specific techniques. You can apply dry pencil to the paper and then brush water over it, or you can pre-wet the brush and directly draw with the pencil tip to create intense, immediate color. This dual-function capability opens up a world of artistic expression, from detailed line work to expansive, atmospheric backgrounds.
Comparing Leading Brands
To help narrow down your choice, comparing the top brands side-by-side is often the most practical approach. Factors such as pigment load, lightfastness, and pencil hardness vary significantly between manufacturers. The following table outlines the general strengths and weaknesses of the most popular options to guide your purchasing decision.
| Brand | Core Type | Best For | Notable Feature |
|---|---|---|---|
| Prismacolor Premier | Soft Wax | Blending & Layering | Creamy, Highly Pigmented |
| Faber-Castell Polychromos | Oil/Wax Blend | Durability & Hardness | Water Resistant & Lightfast |
| Caran d'Ache Luminance | Oil-Based | Precision & Control | Minimal Wax Bloom |
| Derwent Watercolour | Water-Soluble Wax | Mixed Media & Washes | Activates with Water |
Selecting the Right Paper and Surface
Even the highest quality pencils will perform poorly on the wrong surface. The tooth of the paper—the texture—determines how much pigment it can hold. Rough, heavyweight papers are ideal for wax and oil pencils because they grip the cores, allowing for deep color layers. Conversely, hot-pressed surfaces offer a smooth finish better suited for detailed work with oil-based pencils or the watercolor techniques mentioned earlier.
Budget Considerations and Value
Price is always a factor, but it is crucial to distinguish between upfront cost and long-term value. Student-grade pencils are certainly accessible, but they often contain more wax filler and less pigment, leading to frustration and wasted time as you apply multiple layers to achieve a simple color. Investing in a professional-grade set typically pays off in longevity and satisfaction, providing a superior tactile experience and results that are true to the intended hue.