Which Batman Telltale Game Comes First? Order Explained
To understand the Batman narrative within Telltale’s universe, one must first answer the fundamental question: which Batman Telltale game comes first? The answer is not as simple as checking a release date chart, as the studio designed their two major Batman projects as separate, self-contained experiences. However, by examining the timeline, character versions, and narrative dependencies, it becomes clear that the journey begins with Batman: The Enemy Within.
The Dual Identity of Telltale’s Batman
Telltale Games operated during a period where they could leverage the licenses of two distinct eras of Batman. On one hand, there was the iconic Bruce Wayne actively fighting crime in a modern Gotham. On the other, there was the legacy of the character defined by the New 52 comic book relaunch. The confusion often arises because Telltale released a game titled "Batman" long before they released "Batman: The Enemy Within," yet the latter is the chronological starting point. Understanding this distinction is key to navigating the catalog.
Chronological vs. Release Order
Release order tells us that Batman (2016) hit store shelves first, placing players in the cowl of an established vigilante. However, narrative chronology tells a different story. Batman: The Enemy Within (2017) is the true origin story of Telltale’s unique continuity. It introduces the villainous Pact and establishes the dynamic between Bruce Wayne and Selina Kyle within this specific, high-stakes framework. The original "Batman" game actually functions as a sequel within this branched timeline, exploring the aftermath of the events set in motion by The Enemy Within.
Examining The Enemy Within
Batman: The Enemy Within throws the player into the heart of the Pact, a gang of super-villains led by the menacing Joker. The story focuses heavily on character dynamics, particularly the fragile alliance between Batman and Catwoman. The game delves into Bruce’s psychology, exploring the trauma that fuels his mission and the moral compromises he makes to stop the villainous group. Choosing to play this first ensures you meet Telltale’s interpretation of Bruce Wayne and the core cast before they are placed in a different context.
- Narrative Foundation: Establishes the game’s central themes of duality and trust.
- Character Introduction: Brings in key figures like Harley Quinn and the revamped Joker.
- World Building: Defines the rules of Telltale’s Gotham City.
The Case for Starting with the 2016 Batman Game
While The Enemy Within is the chronological starting point, some players prefer to begin with the 2016 release. This version of the game strips away the complex mythology of the Pact and offers a more grounded, personal investigation into the Court of Owls. It serves as an excellent introduction to Telltale's signature "play as Batman" mechanics without the pressure of saving the world from a super-villain conspiracy. It is the simpler of the two, focusing on detective work rather than high-octane combat.
The Connection Between the Two
The relationship between the two games is not one of direct continuation, but of branching consequences. The actions taken by the player in the 2016 game—specifically decisions regarding the Knightfall protocol—ripple forward into The Enemy Within. Conversely, the moral alignment and allegiances established in The Enemy Within create a backdrop that influences the state of Gotham in the earlier title. They are two sides of the same coin, designed to be experienced in a specific order to maximize the emotional and narrative impact.
Maximizing Your Experience
For the optimal understanding of Telltale’s Batman saga, the recommended sequence is clear. Begin with Batman: The Enemy Within to grasp the core mythology and character relationships. Follow this with the 2016 Batman game to see how those foundational events shaped the political and personal landscape of Gotham. This order ensures that references land with weight and the character developments resonate fully. Ignoring this sequence risks missing the subtle callbacks and narrative throughlines that make the universe feel so cohesive.
| Game Title | Release Year | Narrative Position |
|---|---|---|
| Batman: The Enemy Within | 2017 | Chronological First (The Origin) |
| Batman (Telltale) | 2016 | Chronological Second (The Consequence) |